General Music Discussion
#1
This thread is for all general and miscellaneous musical topics that don't have a thread or don't warrant one. I will end up moving most off-topic derailings here. Smile

In other words, this is the "Metal Free-For-All" thread.




[Split from DVD thread]
No disrespect to her predecessors, but she's a bit of a talent upgrade too. Not sure how they managed to land her. I'm amazed (and grateful) she didn't become a solo artist like Rie a.k.a. Suzaku.
My last.fm | Rate Your Music | CDs for sale: Forum, Ebay, and Discogs
Reply
#2
Oh I wouldn't disagree with you there. I don't even like the material before her arrival all that much. Maybe she likes being in a band more than being a solo artist.
Reply
#3
Plus having a fixed lineup (and vocalist) is a really good thing. Eye is as important as Saki in that band. I've always strongly preferred the band dynamic over solo artists (or one guy with a bunch of rent-a-hacks).
My last.fm | Rate Your Music | CDs for sale: Forum, Ebay, and Discogs
Reply
#4
Although I love the band dynamic, I don't share that sentiment, because two of my three all time favorite albums were done by solo artists. However, it doesn't quite work in metal, so I agree to that extent.
Reply
#5
I think outside of metal, it works when the artist does like everything (eg, Kate Bush). If its just a mouthpiece for some ghostwriter, um, no. I also like it when all the musicians have good familiarity/chemistry with each other. Mind you, just a person and a piano kinda bysteps all that.

I find solo projects from bands I like are always missing something. I love Edge of Sanity, but "Moontower" was just missing something. Mind you, I loved Nightingale's first album, so maybe that's an exception there.

I rarely like collaborations or side-projects these days (esp. if its something a label cobbled together). Some of Swano's side projects like Pan-Thy-Monium I like though.
My last.fm | Rate Your Music | CDs for sale: Forum, Ebay, and Discogs
Reply
#6
Kate Bush is a great example. I was thinking more along the lines of Stevie Wonder, who performed 90 percent of the instruments on one of my favorite albums ever.

I think I really liked 'Moontower', but admittedly, it's been an incredibly long time since I last listened to it...
Reply
#7
Moontower was one of those things I wanted to love, but just ended up liking. Crimson II (which was just another Swano solo album) rubbed me the same way. I liked the dynamic/chemistry of the old stuff. Even the hardcore songs I liked (not sure if they fit the albums they were on, but they were fun as fuck anyway). Uncanny how a band could have Bleed and a Sting (or was it The Police?) cover on the same MCD. lol

You know, even that Rami and Fuki Commune feel like they're missing something. I enjoy both, but I like their former bands far more.
My last.fm | Rate Your Music | CDs for sale: Forum, Ebay, and Discogs
Reply
#8
They did 'Invisible Sun', right? That's The Police. Band dynamic! Wink
Reply
#9
Indeed Laugh

I'm guessing certain bands (esp. younger ones) have a certain energy and dynamic that appeals to me. Sometimes, entire scenes. Sweden was in the zone in the 90s, I think. Even mediocre stuff from then was somewhat listenable to me. Well, except The Everdawn.
My last.fm | Rate Your Music | CDs for sale: Forum, Ebay, and Discogs
Reply
#10
If a band uses both outlets, then they're on the right path to success, if they want to be noticed. I agree that there's more of an involvement with the Western scene, but I don't think there's anything wrong with that. If anything, it's probably a plus that the word is getting out there. From personal experience, most metalheads I know got into Asian bands through the likes of Metalucifer, Anthem, and X Japan.

Call me crazy, but since the creation of this forum back in July 2016, I've been seeing more and more posts about classic Japanese metal bands on social media...
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  General Discussion on Japan's Band Battles & Competitions TimJ 30 594 05-24-2018, 04:18 PM
Last Post: TadakatsuH0nda

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)